THE LIE THAT LEADS TO HATE – How Replacement Theology Fuels Antisemitism and Conspiracy Theories
From Neo-Nazism to “From the River to the Sea”—the deadly fruit of a false doctrine that empowers hatred and global deception.
🎙️ EPISODE THREE INTRO
THE LIE THAT LEADS TO HATE – How Replacement Theology Fuels Antisemitism and Conspiracy Theories
Subtitle: From Neo-Nazism to “From the River to the Sea”—the deadly fruit of a false doctrine that empowers hatred and global deception.
INTRO:
You want to know where hatred begins? It doesn’t always start in the streets. Sometimes it starts in the sanctuary.
Today we’re exposing the rotten fruit of Replacement Theology—and let me warn you, it’s not just a theological issue. It’s a weaponized lie that has fueled centuries of antisemitism, empowered neo-Nazi movements, and given rise to conspiracy theories that target Jews, Israel, and even Jesus Himself.
From the Holocaust to Hamas, from church pulpits to digital platforms—it all traces back to the belief that Israel no longer matters to God. That the Jews are finished. That the Church now owns every promise.
That lie has killed. That lie has twisted minds. That lie has spread through Christian circles under banners like “peace,” “justice,” and “truth.” But let me tell you—there’s nothing peaceful about erasing a people God chose. There’s nothing just about stealing their covenant. And there’s no truth in aligning with slogans like “From the River to the Sea,” which literally call for the eradication of the only Jewish nation on earth.
This is more than a doctrinal debate. This is a spiritual war.
And in today’s episode, we’re not just tearing down the lie—we’re going to expose the spiritual powers behind it.
Jesus is coming back to Jerusalem, not Rome. And if your theology makes you blind to that—your theology is broken.
Let’s get to work.
🎙️ You want to know how hatred finds a microphone in the Church?
It doesn’t always start with slurs.
It doesn’t always start with swastikas or war chants.
Sometimes, it starts with a sermon.
A subtle statement.
A theological twist.
A doctrine that quietly erases the people God chose and replaces them with something “better.”
That’s how Replacement Theology has become one of the greatest open doors to antisemitism in Christian history.
It’s not just wrong—it’s dangerous.
It’s not just bad theology—it’s spiritual sabotage.
And it has spilled more Jewish blood than most Christians are even willing to admit.
Today, we’re going to trace the path from doctrine to genocide. From soft preaching to hard hatred. From theological error to conspiracies about Jews, Israel, and the so-called "global elite."
Because when you replace Israel in the Bible… you empower forces that want to erase them from the earth.
Let’s get to work.
🩸 FROM THE PULPIT TO THE GAS CHAMBER
Let’s start with the history most people never hear about in Sunday School.
The Holocaust didn’t begin in 1939.
It didn’t begin in Berlin.
It began in church history.
Centuries before Hitler, the Church had already laid the groundwork for Jewish persecution.
In the 4th century, John Chrysostom called Jews “Christ-killers” and “possessed by demons.”
Augustine, one of the most influential theologians in history, taught that Jews should be left alive only to wander in suffering as a sign of their rejection of Christ.
During the Crusades, Christian knights massacred entire Jewish communities en route to the Holy Land.
Martin Luther, the Reformer himself, wrote in his later years that synagogues should be burned and Jewish homes destroyed.
Let that sink in.
Some of the greatest voices in Christian theology were fueling the fire of antisemitism—all justified by the lie that “the Church replaced Israel.”
By the time Hitler came onto the scene, German churches were already ripe with the fruit of that doctrine.
Hitler didn’t invent Christian antisemitism—he exploited it.
He used “the Jewish problem” as a moral cause, twisted by centuries of theological rot.
In fact, the Nazis published a "De-Judaized Bible"—stripped of the Old Testament and all references to Israel. Sound familiar?
Replacement Theology, taken to its logical end, is not about inclusion—it’s about erasure.
🧨 “FROM THE RIVER TO THE SEA” – A THEOLOGY OF ERASURE
Fast forward to today.
You’ll hear the slogan:
“From the River to the Sea, Palestine will be free.”
Do you know what that means?
It’s not a call for justice. It’s a call for genocide.
It’s a political slogan wrapped in spiritual war paint.
It means the eradication of Israel.
It means no more Jewish state.
It means removing every Jewish family between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea.
This isn’t about land—it’s about existence.
And tragically, you’ll find Christians—especially progressive or liberation-theology Christians—chanting that slogan because they’ve been taught Israel is no longer chosen.
Replacement Theology opened the door to that.
You tell people long enough that Israel doesn’t matter to God, and eventually they believe Israel shouldn’t matter at all.
👹 THE DEMONIC STRATEGY BEHIND IT ALL
Why is this happening? What’s the spiritual agenda?
Satan hates Israel.
Why?
Because the return of Christ is geographically tied to Israel.
Zechariah 14 says Jesus returns and sets His feet on the Mount of Olives.
Revelation 21 says He reigns from the New Jerusalem.
Matthew 23:39 says Jesus told Israel, “You will not see me again until you say, ‘Blessed is He who comes in the name of the Lord.’”
If Satan can wipe out the Jews—or convince the Church they’re irrelevant—he thinks he can delay or derail the return of Christ.
So what does he do?
He fuels lies:
“Israel is a mistake.”
“Jews control the world.”
“The Church replaced Israel.”
“The Jews killed Jesus.”
“Zionism is racism.”
Same lie. Different skin.
Same serpent. New strategy.
🕵️ CONSPIRACY THEORIES: THE “JEWISH GLOBAL ELITE”
Let’s talk about another byproduct of this poison—conspiracy culture.
Thanks to Replacement Theology softening the Church’s view of Israel, it’s now easy for Christians to embrace wild, unbiblical conspiracies that target Jews.
How many times have you heard things like:
“The Rothschilds run the banking system.”
“The Rockefellers created a shadow government.”
“Zionist elites are controlling the media.”
“Israel is behind every war.”
These aren’t just political theories—they’re spiritual warfare dressed in paranoia.
The sad part? Many Christians fall for it.
Why?
Because they’ve already been taught that Jews are no longer important to God. So they’re now fair game for suspicion, slander, and scapegoating.
But Scripture couldn’t be clearer:
“I will bless those who bless you, and him who dishonors you I will curse…” (Genesis 12:3)
If you align yourself against Israel, you’re not being “woke.”
You’re being cursed.
❌ THE CHURCH OF GEOFF STROUD – IGNORANCE ON DISPLAY
Now let’s make this even more personal.
Look at modern teachers like Geoff Stroud, author of the JesusInYou Substack. He pushes Replacement Theology without even realizing the antisemitic freight train he’s hitched a ride on.
He teaches that Israel was “just a shadow,” and now the Church is the fulfillment.
He denies any prophetic role for modern Israel.
He claims the promises of God have been reallocated to the Church.
He has no biblical training. No understanding of Jewish heritage. No fear of misrepresenting God’s covenant.
But he’s got a following—and that’s dangerous.
These kinds of voices become pipelines for half-truths, spiritual confusion, and eventually—alignment with people who literally hate the Jewish people.
This isn’t just careless. It’s catastrophic.
💔 HOW THIS DESTROYS OUR WITNESS
Let me speak to the cost.
When the Church embraces Replacement Theology…
We lose credibility with the Jewish people.
How can we preach Yeshua—the Jewish Messiah—while erasing their covenant?We sever ourselves from our roots.
You cannot understand Jesus without understanding Israel.We become susceptible to every lie about Jews and Israel.
From political to prophetic, from progressive to far-right, we become easy prey for deception.
And worst of all?
We grieve the heart of God.
Because when you lie about Israel, you lie about Him.
✡️ JESUS IS JEWISH
Let’s settle this once and for all:
Jesus is not a white American.
Jesus is not a Gentile pastor.
Jesus is not a universal symbol of vague spirituality.
Jesus. Is. Jewish.
Born in Bethlehem (Micah 5:2)
Raised in Nazareth
Circumcised on the eighth day
Called “Rabbi”
Died under Roman execution on a Jewish Passover
Will return to Jerusalem
You can’t follow Jesus and hate His people.
⚔️ REJECTING REPLACEMENT = RESISTING ANTISEMITISM
So what can we do?
1. Call it what it is.
Don’t sugarcoat it. Replacement Theology is a theological weapon. It breeds antisemitism, confusion, and arrogance.
2. Repent.
If you’ve ever believed or taught this lie—it’s time to repent.
Not just to Israel… but to God.
3. Relearn Scripture.
Go back to Romans 9–11. Read the prophets. Study the covenants. Fall in love with the full story again.
4. Speak up.
When you hear antisemitic jokes, slogans, conspiracies—shut them down. Silence is agreement.
5. Bless Israel.
Not just politically. Not just with your opinions. Pray for her. Speak well of her. Learn from her. Honor her.
“For salvation is from the Jews.” (John 4:22)
🔥 THE WAR OF THE AGES
We’re in a war.
Not of politics.
Not of theology.
But of truth vs. deception.
Satan wants to erase the Jewish people.
And every time the Church agrees—through doctrine, silence, or conspiracy—we join hands with the accuser.
But not us.
Not this generation.
We will not replace Israel.
We will not erase God’s Word.
We will not stand down while lies fill pulpits and platforms.
We are the generation that will bless what God blesses.
We are the generation that will honor every covenant.
And we will stand with Israel until the feet of our King touch down in Jerusalem.
❓ QUESTION OF THE DAY:
Have you ever believed a conspiracy theory about Israel or the Jewish people—and where did that belief come from? Was it Scripture, or was it someone's opinion?
🙏 LET’S PRAY:
Father, open our eyes to deception—wherever it lives.
Give us courage to stand for truth, even when it’s not popular.
Expose every root of Replacement Theology and antisemitism in our hearts and our churches.
Let us honor what You honor. Love whom You love.
And be a Church that stands on the whole truth of Your Word.
In Jesus’ name. Amen.
Let’s Get To Work.
REFERENCE: 1
HUGE CLUE: When someone that you know...calls you a Zionist...
First, Say, "Thank You".
Second, Realize there is NOTHING that you can say OR do...they have chosen their path...sadly, they are blasphemers and Hell is their choice. (You can't call God a liar and think you are welcome in Heaven.)